INDEPENDENT. OPINIONATED. ALWAYS BLUE.WITH THE GRATEFUL HEAD
grateful blueGIANTS FOOTBALL & GOOD COMPANY
← All eight championshipsTHE CHAMPIONSHIP STORIES · 1938

The one we ought to talk about more.

Mel Hein’s MVP season. A lead lost and taken back. A championship decided by the plays New York made when the game asked the most.

GEORGE GUNSHEFSKI · THE GRATEFUL HEAD3 min read · 1938 championship season
NFL Championship Game23–17Giants over the Green Bay Packers
Championship date
December 11, 1938
Regular season
8–2–1
Where it happened
Polo Grounds, New York

The 1938 championship can get squeezed between the Sneakers Game and the names everybody knows from the fifties. I think we owe this team a better seat at the table.

Start with Mel Hein. A center who also played defense, the league’s Most Valuable Player in 1938, doing work that doesn’t fit neatly into a modern highlight package.

A center won MVP. Imagine the argument on television if that happened now. We’d need an extra three hours of programming just to explain that somebody who snaps the ball is also playing football.

Hein was at the heart of an 8–2–1 Giants team coached by Steve Owen. They won the Eastern Division and brought Green Bay to the Polo Grounds with the NFL championship at stake.

You have to finish the possessions.

The Packers moved the ball. By the end, they would have 378 yards to New York’s 212. That is a real advantage, and it also tells you why reading one line of a box score can leave you holding the wrong story.

The Giants blocked two punts and turned those opportunities into an early 9–0 lead. Special teams had given them a way to make Green Bay pay before this became a test of who could pile up more yardage.

The game kept changing. The Packers fought back and took a 17–16 lead in the third quarter. New York had already done enough good things to have a chance. Now the Giants needed another answer.

They got it with a 61-yard drive. Ed Danowski found Hank Soar for a 23-yard touchdown, with Soar going up for the ball against two defenders. The Giants were back in front, 23–17.

Six points to protect.

The fourth quarter produced no scoring. For a Giants fan, that sentence comes with a whole afternoon’s worth of nervous energy attached to it.

Six points is enough to win. It is also close enough to make every first down feel personal. The Giants had to protect the lead they’d earned, and they did.

The newspaper account from Green Bay described a game that carried from daylight into the floodlights. I like that detail because it gives the score somewhere to live. You can picture the afternoon getting later, the same six points still separating the teams, and everyone in the stands waiting for the next snap.

Tuffy Leemans, Danowski, Soar, Hein. These were the names in somebody’s household. Somebody knew their habits and defended them in arguments and expected them to find a way. That part of being a fan hasn’t changed much.

Give this team its due.

Our third championship came from a team that found points through blocked kicks, answered after losing the lead, and held Green Bay scoreless for the final quarter. That is plenty of story.

My grandfather helped give the old Giants a place in my life. Going back through seasons like this makes me want to keep asking questions. Who made the play? Who did the work that let him make it? What did the fans carry home?

In 1938, they carried home another championship. We should say those names a little more often.

Sources & further reading

Official histories, season records, and reporting from the time.

Where does this one live in your family?

Your own memory. A story somebody passed down. There’s room for it here.

Share your Giants memory ↗